Recently, a lady came to see me filled with joy and gratitude for a new car she had bought and wanted us to make a prayer of thanksgiving and dedication to God over the car. We had a great time of prayer, finished and she left. Minutes later, she called me and informed me she had been involved in an accident with the very car we had just prayed over and was on her way to the hospital. Her voice carried shock, confusion, and pain.
She then asked a question that was heavier than the accident itself. She asked me, “Was it wrong for us to pray? Why immediately after the prayers? I honestly feel like God has really let me down!” Her words broke my heart, and I felt deeply sad about the whole situation.
As I thought about what she was saying, I realized that this was not a moment defend the character and name of God. It was not a moment to construct explanations about divine sovereignty or to correct what might have been misplaced expectations. What she was expressing was pain. And pain rarely responds well to argument.
So I just told her I was on my way to go see her wherever she was. I met them with some friends and family and we prayed again. I understood in that moment that what she needed most was not clarification, but presence, understanding, empathy maybe?
Many times when someone experiences a crisis of faith, our first instinct is to react. We feel an urgency to defend God, as though His character depends on our ability to explain Him well. When people lose loved ones, when tragedy strikes hard, when expectation collides with reality, we sometimes rush to correct their thinking before we have acknowledged their wound. We become more concerned with protecting theology than tending to hearts and many times miss the whole point.
There are moments when people are not really looking for explanations, they are trying to make sense of their pain. They are trying to reconcile what they believe with what they are experiencing. In those moments, what they need most is not a polished explanation but a steady presence. They need someone who can sit with their questions without being annoyed by them, someone who can acknowledge the emotion before attempting to interpret the event.
In moments like these, I am reminded that faith is not always fragile because of doubt. Sometimes it is fragile because of pain, and pain does not first require correction, it requires care. When someone feels disappointed by God, rushing to defend Him can unintentionally deepen their isolation. What they are often asking for is not a theological lecture, but reassurance that their anguish is seen and that their questions do not disqualify them from compassion.
There will be time to wrestle with meaning and there will be space to rebuild understanding. But when someone is bleeding, the first ministry is not clarity, it is compassion. The most prudent thing we can do is to sit beside the tension without trying to solve it, trusting that God is not threatened by honest pain and does not require us to defend Him before we have loved His people well.

